This thread is meant to keep an up-to-date journal with star tools' market value.
For every star tool I will keep a buying and a selling price, both with a last-seen date.
I am neither buying nor selling star tools with this thread: this is just meant as a public service, a reference for everyone to refer to, hoping that I'll keep it updated with your honest feedback.

Please reply using the following format:

Spoiler: feedback

Which star tool:
Price (please specify also if it's upfront or payment plan):
Are you just giving a honest estimate (est), or attempting to actually buy/sell at that price (try) or did you actually succeed buying/selling (done):
if (try) are you buying or selling:
if (done), when did this happen?

I myself will reply using this format in the very first comment.


Here are the market prices I've collected so far (pretty empty atm, please provide your feedback!):

Tools

Star pick:
2017-05-16: 1.20M upfront, done
2017-05-28: 1.15M upfront, try sell
2017-07-31: 1.05M upfront, try buy
2017-08-02: 1.10M upfront, try buy

Star axe:
2017-06-11: _900k upfront, done
2017-07-31: _700k upfront, try buy

Star shovel:
2017-05-28: _650k upfront, done

Star rod:
2017-05-10: _825k upfront, estimate
2017-07-04: _800k upfront, done
2017-07-20: _850k upfront, done
2017-08-04: _900k payplan, try buy

Melon sword:
2017-05-28: _975k upfront, done
2017-05-28: 1.15M upfront, done
2017-07-31: _900k upfront, try buy
2017-08-02: _950k upfront, try buy

Combat

Star sword:
(none)

Star bow:
(none)

Star elytra:
(none)

Star rocket:
(none)

Armor

Star helmet:
(none)

Star jacket:
(none)

Star pants:
(none)

Star boots:
(none)

Star shield:
(none)

 

IGN: Expipiplusone
which star tool: star axe
are you buying or selling: buying
price you are willing to buy/sell for: 900k
are you actually buying/selling at that price or is this just your honest attempt to give an estimate: estimate actually bought

 

Updated.
@RazorRimz, if you have a better estimate than mine, you're more than welcome to provide it. I just took it out of my ass using a "reasonable" value for nstars @600/pc, but I don't really know the actual market value of an off-the-shelf tool

 

I assumed your "optimistic" meant you disagreed on my out-of-the-ass estimate XD nevermind

 

added, thanks

 

IGN: Expipiplusone
which star tool: star pick
are you buying or selling: selling
price you are willing to buy/sell for: 1.3M
are you actually buying/selling at that price or is this just your honest attempt to give an estimate: estimate

 

IGN: Expipiplusone
which star tool: pick
are you buying or selling: selling
price you are willing to buy/sell for: 1.2Mil
are you actually buying/selling at that price or is this just your honest attempt to give an estimate: selling sold

 

@THCOOL and @Ladyvamptress: added, thank you.
Also, I changed the format following TH's advice and updated the presentation of results.
@Drewbo_: I assume your estimate for the rod was for an upfront payment, am I correct?

 

Added, thank you

 

Updated to include this

 

Added (thanks) and updated format

 

Added star shield!
(if you find a 32x32 picture of it, please let me know. I could just make one and upload it on imgur, but i'd rather use one already available and possibly official)