SG2 was a very unpopular map, it had a really small amount of chests and most of the secret places, which is where most of the chests are, were broken due to the rollbacks and disabling redstone.
It was rare to see that arena getting filled.


I think the problem isn't that maps are unpopular. The maps aren't actually unpopular, we just don't have enough people to fill all the arenas. (So people will flock the most popular arenas and no one is left for the other arenas) No matter what you do, arena 2-4 will always be full and arena 1 will be fairly busy. (during on-peak)
and 5-8 are less popular, but if the other arenas are full they get busy as well.

The problem is that we don't have enough SG players.

 

I'm not a fan of post-apocalyptic maps like the old SG4 or just generally huge maps like the old SG2. Although I would like to be able to go back and find the easter egg on the snow map again, I don't see anything wrong with the current arenas. -1

 

+1
This might be nice if the 1/8 non-kit idea is implemented. I would like to have a new arena no one has played in a while be the start of a new line of sg.

 

I liked the old jungle map, that one was cool. The issue was that it was way too big, like out current SG 1. If they were made smaller, I'd be all for the idea, if not, -1.

 

Mee too :D

 

Remove sg 1 please! It takes forever to play 1 Game!

 

I totally agree that we should bring back SG 4. It was my favorite SG map back then. I don't remember sg 2 though enough to make a comment either way.

 

Here's a screenshot from SG 2, I believe this is SG 2 from back in the old days with ender pearls :p.

 

That's sg4 you noob

 

I really like sg 5 and sg 7 so if this was implimented, I'd like for those to stay.

 

Sg 4 nub, and this was my favorite map. I knew where 95% of the chests were and I could sorta anticipate where people would be at certain times. Please @Revanrose6 convince andrewkm to add the old sg 4 back!!!!

 

Here is the old sg 2. Its pretty dark.

Spoiler: lol

 

Also, one of the reasons I think sg 4 was removed was because of all the glitching snow.

 

Just change all 8 arenas into different maps.

 

I loved sg 4 and I remember someone who quit right after it was deleted. Maybe if he heard it came back he would come back too..
Anyways, +1!