I agree. This type of information can help someone improve their application the next time around, and it also provides outsider prospective on what other people think they need to improve on. This is something very few have the ability to do on their own, and there's nothing wrong with getting advice for others.

 

The Rules of that forum say only post when you have crucial feedback so I believe it is already in place just not enforced. @Revanrose6 Can you shed some light on this matter?

 

Format?

 

XD +1

 

Well, In a sense, If the Admins/Staff took into consideration the feedback and user votes (Which they don't) This would matter yet as they don't in my opinion, it doesn't. Sorry. -1

 

Oh, ok, I get it know. +1

 

They don't take users posts into consideration, they only look at the staff app. People just post because they want to show their support for the applicant.

 

No. If staff doesn't even look at it, they should not have to waste their time on something so unnecessary. Application posting is already extremely biased, so someone would give you a -1 for scamming or a +1 because you're their friend. Simply ask them for an explanation in a conversation or even on the application itself. It does not need to be enforced, it would be a waste of time.

 

+1 completely agree I just lectured a player yesterday for his comments on others app and this player keeps doing -1 on everyone and refuses to give reasons Xp

however in fairness andrew does make the final decision, they can have their own opinion, and they are under no obligation to answer u.

I still think this is a good idea

 

I know. Exactly what I said xP. ^^

 

-1

 

Lel, someone had to do it.

In any case, this seems too harsh. Players shouldn't be REQUIRED to provide an explanation, if an applicant wants one, they can simply ask.

 

Let's be honest though, if they make it so you have to put a reason, we'll invent one on the spot.

 

Lol, this is probably what would happen.

 

I try to either award a like or winner thing on the original post if i have nothing to say on the app.

Would be nice if people would have to explain why they +1 or -1 an application.

+1

 

No

No, you said "(which they don't)". I explained, not just stated, why people add the +1/-1 and said that they only look The staff application in a way that makes sense.